Files
doctoral-research-groups/method/monash_v2__counter_examples.md

16 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Monash v2 · 反例 / 判不准 / 未验清单

1. 反例(判它不是组,逐条附页面原文)

# 页面 判定依据(页面原文/形态)
1 /emerging-tech-research-lab(Emerging Technologies Research Lab) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
2 /consciousness-contemplative-studies(Monash Centre for Consciousness and) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
3 /bioniceye(Monash Vision Group) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
4 /it/environmental-informatics-hub(Environmental Informatics Hub) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
5 /business/mcfs/our-research/all-projects/retirement-and-superannuation/impact-and-engagement(Mercer CFA Institute Global Pension) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
6 /law/research/centres-and-groups/feminist-legal-studies-group/about-us(Feminist Legal Studies Group) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
7 /medicine/sphpm/austrim(Australian Trials Methodology Resea) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
8 /business/economics/research/research-groups/dehipe(Development, History, and Political) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
9 /business/economics/research/research-groups/ioat(Industrial Organisation and Applied) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
10 /arts/acjc/monash-initiative-for-rapid-research-into-antisemitism-mirra(The Monash Initiative for Rapid Res) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
11 /medicine/her-centre/research/thred-transformative-hub-for-research-into-eating-disorders(The Li Transformative Hub for Resea) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
12 /business/impact-labs/energy-lab/research-networks/aemi(Australian Electricity Market Initi) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
13 /medicine/translational/infectious-diseases/research/groups/wright-group(Wright Group) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
14 /arts/Ibn-Arabi-Interreligious-Research-Initiative(Ibn Arabi Interreligious Research I) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
15 /arts/acjc/monash-initiative-for-rapid-research-into-antisemitism-mirra/the-monash-initiative-for-rapid-research-into-antisemitism-mirra(The Monash Initiative for Rapid Res) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
16 /arts/cognition-and-philosophy-lab(Monash Centre for Consciousness and) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文
17 /law/research/centres/warrencentre/about-us/from-ACJI-to-the-Warren-Centre(From ACJI to the Warren Centre for ) NOT_GROUP 自述命中(project / initiative / platform / partnership 等);原文见页面正文

| 18 | /medicine/translational/neuroscience/research/monif-group/australian-autoimmune-encephalitis-consortium(Australian Autoimmune Encephalitis ) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 19 | /medicine/translational/neuroscience/australian-autoimmune-encephalitis-consortium(Australian Autoimmune Encephalitis ) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 20 | /medicine/ehcs/marc/groups/burnet-institute(Burnet Institute) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 21 | /engineering/resources-trinity/critical-minerals-consortium(Critical Minerals Consortium) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 22 | /mips/themes/medicine-safety/major-projects-clinical-trials/deprescribing-in-guidelines-international-consortium(Deprescribing in Guidelines Interna) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 23 | /energy-institute/grid-innovation-hub(GRID INNOVATION HUB) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 24 | /engineering/mti(Maintenance Technology Institute) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 25 | /ai-institute(Monash AI Institute) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 26 | /ai-data-science(Monash AI Institute) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 27 | /data-futures-institute(Monash AI Institute) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 28 | /discovery-institute(Monash Biomedicine Discovery Instit) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 29 | /discovery-institute/departments/biochemistry-and-molecular-biology/about-us(Monash Biomedicine Discovery Instit) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 30 | /discovery-institute/departments/microbiology/about-us(Monash Biomedicine Discovery Instit) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 31 | /discovery-institute/departments/pharmacology/about-us(Monash Biomedicine Discovery Instit) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 32 | /discovery-institute/departments/physiology/about-us(Monash Biomedicine Discovery Instit) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 | | 33 | /discovery-institute/mackay-lab(Monash Biomedicine Discovery Instit) | 大一级(institute / National Centre / research network)——不是导师组 |

| 34 | /education/research/groups(Faculty Research and Scholarship Gr) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 35 | /business/research/our-research/impact-labs(Impact Labs) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 36 | /business/research/impact-labs(Impact Labs) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 37 | /business/impact-labs(Impact Labs) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 38 | /turner-institute/research-labs(Research labs) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 39 | /mada/research/labs(Art, Design and Architecture) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 40 | /mada/transforming-cities-hub/projects(Art, Design and Architecture) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) | | 41 | /mada/design-health-collab/projects(Design Health Collab) | 目录/容器页(labs/groups/centres 索引) |

2. 判不准清单(拿不准的都在这里,不自己发明规则归类)

# 条目 我看到的 为什么拿不准
1 86 个 centre 级候选(MCFS / RAIL / CCRET / CYPEP / MCHRI / MonCOEH / ACBD / MARC / CMUS …) 有独立页、有方向、有负责人;自述 centre 「中心」常是多 PI 聚合,超出「一个导师能带的规模」;但部分中心(如 Clinical Psychedelic Lab 同级规模)确实是单导师团队
2 Business Impact Labs(Digital / Green / FinTech / Energy / Mutual Value / Opportunity Tech / SoDa) 有独立页、有方向、有 PI 自述 hub / lab;跨学科 hub vs 导师组边界模糊
3 IT 的 HCC / DSAI / SSC 系内 research cluster 页 有方向、有成员 系内 cluster 是不是组
4 Turner Institute 30 个 <PI> Lab 全部有具名 PI、方向明确 本波按组收(判定标准最清楚的一批)
5 Malaysia 校区的 Gerontechnology Lab / Fintech Impact Lab / CLARS-MH / SEADS 有独立页 多数 school research 页只给 theme、未点单一 PI;是否按组收取决于口径
6 MIPS 的 3 个 Theme(Medicinal Chemistry / Drug Delivery / Optimisation) 有 theme 页 大一级,本波只收 Theme 下的 research group(22 条)
7 MUARC(Accident Research Centre)/ ISCRR(University Institute) 中心/校级研究所 大一级
8 /medicine/scs/research/<topic>(Bone and Muscle / Critical Care / Aged Mental Health Unit …) 学校把它们列为 Research 列表项,部分无具名负责人 单元 vs 组

3. 未验 / 取不到清单(显式列出,不静默跳过)

# 条目 卡点(URL / 错误原文)
1 部分页面 page.fetch 跨源被 CORS 拦截(重定向到别的 host) 188 条 Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS
2 HTTP 404 39 条(多为旧 URL / 已合并页)
3 HTTP 403 12 条
4 非 HTML 响应 10 条(PDF 等)
5 research.monash.edu(Pure 门户,717 链接) 未按「组」逐页收录;它给的是 organisations/persons/publications 指纹,不是导师组描述页
6 supervisorconnect.med.monash.edu(153 链接)/ supervisorconnect.it.monash.edu 研究生导师目录,未作为组枚举入口(身份核对用)
7 Science Biology 的组页 组名多为 topic/PI 命名(如 staff2/<name>),本波按「有独立页面 + 具名的人 + 方向文字」收,收得比 Chemistry 少;已定位未逐个核完
8 MUARC / Monash Energy Institute / Monash AI Institute 等中心内部 只到中心页,中心内部具名组未逐条取 H1
9 Malaysia 校区各 school 的 research theme 页 多数只给主题与人员列表,未点单一 PI;未按组收
10 ego-browser 版本 0.5.1.13;运行中出现过一次 TaskSpace 被回收 已新建 TaskSpace 并从一开始就 checkpoint(pages.jsonl),无产物丢失

3.1 错误样本(前 40 条)

status/error URL
404 HTTP_404 https://www.monash.edu/mada/about-us/our-departments
404 HTTP_404 https://www.monash.edu/research/institutes
403 HTTP_403 https://www.monash.edu/blockchain
403 HTTP_403 https://monash.edu/mime/
403 HTTP_403 https://monash.edu/pharm/research/centres-institutes/medicine-safety/
404 HTTP_404 https://www.monash.edu/sustainable-development
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/it/ailecs
404 HTTP_404 https://www.monash.edu/mada/research/our-approach/reimagining-cities/building-4.0-crc
404 HTTP_404 https://www.monash.edu/mada/research/our-approach/expansive-visions-and-technologies/building-4.0-cr
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/mada/xyx-lab/people/dr-whitney-monaghan
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/constructive-institute-asia-pacific-hub/redirects/deb-anderson
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/constructive-institute-asia-pacific-hub/redirects/stephanie-brookes
200 NON_HTML:application/pdf https://www.monash.edu/business/research/pact/how-we-work/2024/a-next-generation-of-climate-laws-in-
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/business/baf/our-research/impact-showcase
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/business/baf/impact-and-engagement/research-showcase
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/business/research/pact/assets/redirects/youtube-pact-introduction
404 HTTP_404 https://www.monash.edu/msdi
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/business/economics/research/research-showcase
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/business/marketing/our-research/research-projects-and-impact
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/education/cypep/research/the-2025-australian-youth-barometer-understanding-yo
403 HTTP_403 https://www.monash.edu/engineering/eng-dev/our-research/research-institutes-and-centres
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/monash-innovation-labs/enquiry-form
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/energy-institute/re-direct-links/internal-signup_the-energy-brief
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/energy-institute/re-direct-links/linkedin-page
403 HTTP_403 https://www.monash.edu/researchinfrastructure/mbi-old
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/it/research/supervisor-connect
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/nursing/research/projects
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/sphpm/assets/re-directs/dfm-research-program
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/sphpm/units/cochrane-australia
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/medical-school/staff-intranet
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/mchri/nested-content/mchri-consumer-pages
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research-facilities/monash-live-biobanking-molbi-platform/team/m
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research-facilities/monash-live-biobanking-molbi-platform/team/t
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research-facilities/monash-live-biobanking-molbi-platform/team/z
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research-facilities/monash-live-biobanking-molbi-platform/team/g
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research-facilities/monash-live-biobanking-molbi-platform/team/e
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research-facilities/monash-live-biobanking-molbi-platform/team/b
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research/drug-and-alcohol
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research/forensic-psychiatry
Error: page.fetch uses window.fetch and obeys browser CORS. https://www.monash.edu/medicine/scs/research/rural-psychiatry