26 KiB
26 KiB
课题组逐院系 · 完备性重做 · 爱丁堡大学（University of Edinburgh）· ed.ac.uk
- 日期：2026-09-23 · Manager 波次 · 单校 · 只读
- 方式：ego-browser（自建 TaskSpace 67，每个 URL 用独占的新
newPage()，逐页校验page.url()）+ curl 并行抓取做规模，浏览器复核 - 前一轮：
finding_edinburgh.md（22 组）——本报告推翻其结论：22 组只覆盖了「组页目录」的一小角，且完全没进 IGC / Biology / Inflammation / IRR 四个大池 - 产物：
edinburgh_v2__groups.json（643 条逐页核实的五字段产物）edinburgh_v2__ledger.md（§1 那张台账）- 本文
0. 结论先行
这所学校最终组数是 643（其中 617 落在官方 24 个 School 下，另 26 条是学院级 Research Centres，单列）。
前一轮 22 组不是判据问题，是覆盖问题：它只收了「School → 中心/研究组」的目录页， 而爱丁堡真正的大头是四个由院系自己发布的 PI 组名录—— School of Biological Sciences（140 组，页面原文 "more than 130 research groups … each led by a Principal Investigator"）、 Institute of Genetics and Cancer（83 组）、Centre for Inflammation Research（57 组）、Institute for Regeneration and Repair（CRM 26 + CRH 22 = 48 组）、Usher Institute（24 组）。 这 352 条每一条都有具名 PI，本身就是「导师带的组」的标准形态，不抓它们，数量永远对不上。
1. 完备性台账（官方 24 个 School）
枚举来源（院系清单）：
- 官方导航：
https://www.ed.ac.uk/schools-departments/colleges-schools→ 3 个 College + 24 个 School + Centre for Open Learning（非研究单位） - 查漏辅助：
https://www.ed.ac.uk/schools-departments/sub-units（官方 Sub-units, centres & institutes A–Z，210 条实体；JS 渲染，用浏览器取得） - 参考（非院系枚举）：
/schools-departments/associated-institutions（关联机构，非本校研究单位）
| # | 院系（School） | research 入口 URL | 状态 | 组数 | 备注 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Business School | https://www.business-school.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 17 | 6 中心 + 12 实验室/网络 + 1 研究所；subject groups/themes 不收 |
| 2 | School of Divinity | https://divinity.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 8 | 4 中心 + 4 网络 |
| 3 | School of Economics | https://economics.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 0 | 该系不按组组织：只有 Seminars / Publications / Discussion papers / Focus papers / Research Projects / Ethics，无 groups/centres 页（/research/research-groups、/research/research-areas 均 404） |
| 4 | Edinburgh College of Art | https://www.eca.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 30 | /groups-and-clusters 3 页分页，全部取得 |
| 5 | Moray House School of Education and Sport | https://education-sport.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 25 | 7 中心 + 13 组 + 5 网络（含跨院系的 1 条） |
| 6 | School of Health in Social Science | https://health.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 15 | 5 中心 + 10 组/网络；同页 ~55 个单项研究 study 不收（见 §5-1） |
| 7 | School of History, Classics and Archaeology | https://hca.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 9 | 5 中心（+leventis 等）+ History 的 5 个 research group（同一页分节） |
| 8 | School of Law | https://www.law.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 14 | 12 中心 + 2 网络；10 个 research areas / 3 个 research themes 不收 |
| 9 | School of Literatures, Languages and Cultures | https://llc.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 21 | 目录页列 23 条，2 条无独立页已按目录计入；Expanding Cinema 与 ECA 共页（去重） |
| 10 | School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences | https://ppls.ed.ac.uk/research-and-impact |
取到 | 8 | Philosophy 1 / Psychology 3 / Linguistics 6，去重后 8（CDCS 三系共有） |
| 11 | School of Social and Political Science | https://sps.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 17 | /centres 列 22 条；AQMEN、Q-Step、Q-Step Academy、Research Training Centre（4 条培训/服务）不收；Binks Hub、Engineering Life（平台/项目）不收 |
| 12 | Edinburgh Medical School | https://medicine-vet-medicine.ed.ac.uk/edinburgh-medical-school |
取到 | 18 | Biomedical Sciences 5 + Pathology 8 + Surgery 4 + Clinical Brain Sciences 1；Discovery Brain Sciences 与 Clinical Brain 其余条目是 theme |
| 13 | Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies | https://vet.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 17 | 12 个 Division（含 Roslin 8 个 Division，去重） |
| 14 | School of Genetics and Cancer | https://medicine-vet-medicine.ed.ac.uk/school-of-genetics-and-cancer |
取到 | 83 | IGC Research Groups A-Z 全量；另 5 个 Research Theme、2 个 Funded Centre（MRC HGU / CRUK）不收；~45 个 Affiliate 教师不收（他们不是独立组） |
| 15 | School of Population Health Sciences | https://medicine-vet-medicine.ed.ac.uk/school-of-population-health-sciences |
取到 | 24 | Usher Institute：Medical Informatics 6 + Population Health Sciences 11 + Global Health 7 |
| 16 | School of Regeneration and Repair | https://medicine-vet-medicine.ed.ac.uk/school-of-regeneration-and-repair |
取到 | 105 | IRR：Centre for Inflammation Research 57 + Centre for Regenerative Medicine 26 + Centre for Reproductive Health 22 |
| 17 | School of Neurological and Cardiovascular Sciences | https://medicine-vet-medicine.ed.ac.uk/school-of-neurological-and-cardiovascular-sciences |
取到 | 0 | 缺口：CVS 只给 4 个 theme（自述 49 PI），INCR 只给 1,200+ staff / PI A–Z 索引，无具名组页（见 §5-3） |
| 18 | School of Biological Sciences | https://biology.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 140 | 页面原文 "more than 130 research groups in the School, each led by a Principal Investigator"；表格 140 行全取（8 组无独立站点，见 §5-4） |
| 19 | School of Chemistry | https://chem.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 0 | 缺口：只有 6 个 Research Theme；/research/research-groups 原文 "Many of our research groups have their own website. These will be added here as they are available."（见 §5-3） |
| 20 | School of Engineering | https://www.eng.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 10 | 7 个 Institute（大一级，不收）+ 各所 "Research activity" 下的具名组/实验室 10 个；~35 个 research theme 不收 |
| 21 | School of GeoSciences | https://geosciences.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 15 | /research/research-groups 全量；3 个 Institute（大一级）不收 |
| 22 | School of Informatics | https://informatics.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 34 | LFCS 9 + IPAB 10 + ICSA 5 + ILCC 5（+ 个别跨所）；6 个 Institute 本身不收 |
| 23 | School of Mathematics | https://www.maths.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 4 | 页面自称 "Research groups"，实际是 4 个大批次（含 25 staff 的 Analysis & Probability）；flagged 见 §5-5 |
| 24 | School of Physics and Astronomy | https://www.ph.ed.ac.uk/research |
取到 | 3 | IPNP 下 3 个组（原文 "comprises three research groups"）；ICMCS 7 个 theme、IfA、4 个校级中心不收 |
| — | 小计（24 School） | 617 | |||
| + | College 级 Research Centres（S&E） | https://science-engineering.ed.ac.uk/research/centres |
取到 | 26 | 不属于任何单一 School，单列（CIIE / CRESH / CSEC / CSTR / DCC / ECCI / EPCC / HCRC / Higgs / CfS / CANPDE …） |
| 合计 | 643 |
取不到：无（24 个 School 的 research 入口全部 200 取到）。个别 Group 页取不到，逐条列在 §5-3。
2. 子域 / 外站清单（全部跟过）
爱丁堡的研究单位极度分散。本次抓到 165 个不同主机，其中：
- 117 个
*.ed.ac.uk子域（含 30+ 个学院自有子域和 20+ 个<pi>.bio.ed.ac.uk个人站点） - 39 个完全不在
ed.ac.uk下的外站
不在 ed.ac.uk 下的外站（39 个，不跟就整块漏掉）：
2dml-lab.github.io、avaxman.github.io、briansteidinger.weebly.com、cheerambathurlab.co.uk、cresh.org.uk、enigma-li.github.io、ewallace.github.io、koestlerunit.wordpress.com、ksubr.github.io、laurarossedinburgh.weebly.com、lukemcnally.wordpress.com、matthartfield.wordpress.com、mattjsilk.weebly.com、patrickwildcentre.com、peronalab.uk、sadlerlab.github.io、saramaciasribela.wixsite.com、sejohnston.com、simonmartinlab.org、sites.google.com、swafferlab.co.uk、tagawa-lab.org、www.bilingualism-matters.org、www.bucklab.org、www.connectingmemories.org、www.crosby-lab.com、www.designinformatics.org、www.edinburghcentre.org、www.mdwilsonlab.com、www.mooney-lab.com、www.rbge.org.uk、www.sccs.org.uk、www.sidb.org.uk、www.statmt.org、www.stracquadaniolab.org、www.theplantshapelab.org、www.thesibleylab.com、www.wellswoodresearchgroup.com、www.youngtoxolab.com
主要 ed.ac.uk 子域（节选，按抓取量）：
institute-genetics-cancer、inflammation-research、biology、www.eca、regenerative-medicine、education-sport、reproductive-health、usher、vet、geosciences、health、www.law、llc、www.crm、informatics、www.eng、hca、pathology、divinity、surgery、www.maths、www.ph、www.chem、www.business-school、web.inf、homepages.inf、groups.inf、blogs、clinical-brain-sciences、discovery-brain-sciences、edinburgh-infectious-diseases、www.cdcs、www.alzscotdrc、www.amc.lel、www.lel、buddhist-studies、cei.bio、ciie.bio、ctcb.bio、www.csec、www.eid、www.epcc、www.hcrc、www.wcb、centreforstatistics.maths、higgs.ph、www.fire.eng、www.smc.eng、www.plasmatheory、www.exoplanets、biomedical-physics、www.cstr、www.icsa.inf、netsys.inf、easelab.inf、mi.inf、mig.inf、edinburghnlp.inf、www.skape、www.csas、www.cst、www.ceser.sps、critique.sps、ghpu.sps、www.issti、www.europa、rri、www.gender、www.race、www.san、www.ces 等。
关键教训：Business School 的 12 个 Lab、Biology 的 20+ 个 PI 站点、SPS 的 15 个中心全部不在
www.ed.ac.uk下。只抓主域必漏。
3. 组 / 系 比值与合理性校验
- 官方 24 个 School；本次逐页核实 643 组（其中 617 落在 24 个 School 下，26 条学院级中心单列）。
- 组/系 = 617 ÷ 24 ≈ 25.7（含学院级中心 643 ÷ 24 ≈ 26.8）。
- 基准：布里斯托 ≈5.8（174 / ~30 系）。爱丁堡 ≈25.7，远高于基准，不需要"往下挖一层"的解释。
该校的院系确实大量用 theme / institute 组织（大一级），但底下都挂着真组，且这层真组本次已经收上来：
| 院系 | 大一级组织 | 底下挂着的具名组（本次已收） |
|---|---|---|
| School of Biological Sciences | 6 个 Institute + 5 个 Strategic Theme | 140 个 PI 组（表格逐行展开） |
| School of Genetics and Cancer | 5 个 Research Theme + 2 个 Funded Centre | 83 个 X Research Group（A–Z 全量） |
| School of Regeneration and Repair | IRR 1 个 Institute | CIR 57 + CRM 26 + CRH 22 = 105 组 |
| School of Population Health Sciences | Usher Institute | 24 个 Group |
| School of Informatics | 6 个 Institute | LFCS 9 + IPAB 10 + ICSA 5 + ILCC 5 = 29 组（另 AIAI 等跨所） |
| School of GeoSciences | 3 个 Institute + 2 个 Centre | 15 个 research group |
| School of Engineering | 7 个 Institute + ~35 个 theme | 各所 Research activity 下 10 个具名组/实验室 |
| School of Physics and Astronomy | IPNP / ICMCS 2 个 Institute + 7 个 theme | IPNP 下 3 个组 |
"再下一层没有具名组"的证据（原文结构）：
- School of Chemistry：
/research/research-themesH1="Research Themes"，6 个 theme；/research/research-groupsH1="Research Groups"，正文只有一句 "Many of our research groups have their own website. These will be added here as they are available." + "This article was published on Wednesday 12 February 2025"。页面没有任何第二层组链接 → 化学的 PI 组在院系层没有枚举入口（见 §5-3）。 - CVS（School of Neurological and Cardiovascular Sciences）：
/researchH1="Research"，正文 "Information on the research goals, projects, and principal investigators within each of the four CVS research themes (MOD, HART, CINEMA, and Coronary and Valvular Heart Disease)" → 有 49 个 PI 但只按 4 个 theme 聚合，无逐 PI 组页。 - Discovery Brain Sciences：
/our-research下仅有 5 个 theme 页（Ageing and Degeneration / Genes and Development / Injury and Repair / Signalling Homeostasis and Energy Balance / Synapses Circuits and Behaviour），无更细具名组页。 - School of Economics：
/research章节为 Seminars / Publications / Discussion papers / Focus papers / Research Projects / Ethics，没有组层。
4. 抽样 15 条五字段产物（浏览器逐页复核，page.url() 校验通过）
| # | 课题组名称（页面 h1） | 所在大学及研究中心 | 研究方向（页面原文节选） | 联系邮箱 | 最近五年论文数 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | EPIGENETIC MECHANISMS MEDIATING FUNGICIDE AND ANTIFUNGAL RESISTANCE | University of Edinburgh | Antifungal resistance in pathogenic fungi endangers global health and world food supplies. The limited number of effective antifungal drugs makes treatment of infected patients challenging. | robin.allshire@ed.ac.uk | null |
| 2 | Ian Adams Research Group | University of Edinburgh | Institute of Genetics and Cancer | Our research is trying to find out how the body makes sure that parents pass the right number of chromosomes to their children, and how errors in this process can lead to cancer. | Ian.Adams@ed.ac.uk | null |
| 3 | Professor Ahsan Akram | University of Edinburgh | Centre for Inflammation Research | We study how cells in the tumour microenvironment influence tumour progression and outcome, using advanced imaging and molecular techniques. | ahsan.akram@ed.ac.uk | null |
| 4 | Pierre Bagnaninchi Research Group | University of Edinburgh | Institute for Regeneration and Repair | Our main research interest is the development of label-free quantitative technologies to monitor stem cell behaviour and tissue engineering constructs. | pierre.bagnaninchi@ed.ac.uk | null |
| 5 | GraphViX | University of Edinburgh | IPAB | GraphViX is a research group working on graph visualization, visual analytics and human-computer interaction for graph data. | — | null |
| 6 | Acoustics and Audio Group | University of Edinburgh | The Acoustics and Audio Group at the University of Edinburgh currently consists of eight academic staff and around a dozen postgraduate students. It has members and associations across the University. | a.myers@ed.ac.uk | null |
| 7 | Centre for Research in Education Inclusion and Diversity (CREID) | University of Edinburgh | Our research informs policy and practice in the pursuit of equality, social justice and social inclusion in education. | creid-education@ed.ac.uk | null |
| 8 | SKAPE (Centre for Science, Knowledge and Policy) | University of Edinburgh | SKAPE conducts innovative and critical research on the relationship between knowledge and policy. | — | null |
| 9 | Institute for Public Sector Accounting Research | University of Edinburgh | IPSAR brings together researchers studying public sector accounting, accountability and governance. | — | null |
| 10 | Edinburgh Centre for Buddhist Studies | University of Edinburgh | The Edinburgh Centre for Buddhist Studies (ECBS) brings together researchers from across the University of Edinburgh and the north of the UK, for academic and outreach events relating to the study of Buddhism. | — | null |
| 11 | Centre for Legal History | University of Edinburgh | The Centre for Legal History provides a lively social and scholarly focus for the active research community in Edinburgh working on the history of law. | — | null |
| 12 | Atmospheric Chemistry and Climate of the Anthropocene | University of Edinburgh | The Atmospheric Chemistry and Climate of the Anthropocene research group investigates key processes and drivers in the atmosphere and climate system, and predicts present-day and future changes in climate, atmospheric composition and air quality. | — | null |
| 13 | Centre for Homelessness and Inclusion Health | University of Edinburgh | The Centre for Homelessness and Inclusion Health brings together researchers and practitioners to improve health and inclusion for people experiencing homelessness. | — | null |
| 14 | Analysis and Probability | University of Edinburgh | The Analysis and Probability research theme covers a broad spectrum from harmonic analysis and probability theory to pure and applied PDEs, with applications in data science and machine learning, finance and economics. | — | null |
| 15 | A. G. Leventis Centre for Greek Studies | University of Edinburgh | Edinburgh's A. G. Leventis Centre for Greek Studies: Ancient, Byzantine, Modern (AGLCGS) organises seminars, conferences and research collaboration in Greek studies. | — | null |
字段观察：
课题组名称：436/643 取自页面 H1；159/643 用<title>回退（站点无 H1）；48/643 用院系目录里的官方组名（页面本身是 JS 渲染或表格行，见 §5-4）。三种来源都在 JSON 的_name_source里标了。所在大学及研究中心：只有上级是真正的 research institute/centre 才写University of Edinburgh | <unit>（IGC、CIR、IRR、CRH、Usher、LFCS/IPAB/ICSA/ILCC、IPNP）；上级是 School/Department 的一律只写大学。联系邮箱：288/643 在组自己页面上有邮箱；其余要进 PI 个人页才能拿，本波没有为凑字段去别处抓（留空）。研究方向：609/643 有页面原文方向；34 条页面无方向叙述，留空（用户裁定：没有就不要）。最近五年论文数：643/643 null（用户裁定）。
5. 反例 / 判不准 / 未验
5-1 反例清单（判它不是组，附页面原文）
| # | 页面 | 判定依据（页面原文） |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | health.ed.ac.uk/research/current-research/thistledown-project |
页名即 "Project"；同页并列 A Public Inconvenience、Road to Recovery、Paws on Campus、CREATE Dance for Dementia、My Grief My Way、Illegal Puppy Trade… 等 ~55 条单项研究 study（Health in Social Science 的 "current research" 页是组与项目混排） |
| 2 | sps.ed.ac.uk → AQMEN |
原文 "AQMEN is an established provider of training, capacity building and knowledge exchange activities in the area of statistical methods" —— 培训/服务，非导师组 |
| 3 | sps.ed.ac.uk → Edinburgh Q-Step Centre / Q-Step Academy |
原文 "The Edinburgh Q-Step Centre equips students with…" / "provides free training" —— 学生培养/培训 |
| 4 | sps.ed.ac.uk → Research Training Centre |
原文 "applies expertise in a diverse range of training and capacity-building activities" —— 方法培训服务 |
| 5 | sps.ed.ac.uk → Binks Hub |
原文 "a partnership of individuals, organisations, artists, and academic researchers" —— 合作平台 |
| 6 | sps.ed.ac.uk → Engineering Life (el.sps.ed.ac.uk) |
原文 "The Engineering Life project focuses on the emerging field…" —— 项目 |
| 7 | health.ed.ac.uk/.../paws-on-campus |
单项研究 study（人与动物的干预研究），无团队自述 |
| 8 | vet.ed.ac.uk/roslin/research → "Animal research" |
指向 ed.ac.uk/research-innovation/animal-research —— 机构合规/设施说明 |
| 9 | PPLS 语言学 …/research/talks-and-reading-groups/（Linguistic Circle、Bilingualism research group、Historical phonology reading group、Sociolinguistics reading group） |
原文页名即 reading group / talk series —— 读书小组/讲座系列 |
| 10 | School of Engineering …/research/activity/*-journal-club（Carbon Capture & Storage Journal Club、Smart Grid Journal Club、Marine and Environmental Fluid Dynamics Journal Club、Energy Storage Discussion Group） |
原文即 Journal Club / Discussion Group —— 研讨会系列 |
| 11 | Chemistry /research/research-groups |
只有一句 "These will be added here as they are available." —— 空目录页，不是组 |
| 12 | IGC /research/research-groups-a-z/affiliates（~45 人） |
原文 "scientists, clinicians and academics from outside our Institute" —— 跨聘个人，每人另有主业组，不重复计 |
| 13 | IGC /research/funded-centres（MRC HGU / CRUK Scotland Centre） |
资助中心（大一级），且其组已在 A–Z 内逐一计入，不重复 |
| 14 | Business School /research/areas/*（Accounting & Finance、Marketing、Strategy …） |
Subject group = 系级组织单元，非导师组；/research/themes/* 同理 |
| 15 | Business School "Cater for Climate" / "Project Fair" | 倡议/项目页 |
反例的共同点仍是那句**「非团队自述」**：
project、partnership、training、reading group、journal club、these will be added。没有一条需要靠名字猜。
5-2 判不准清单（拿不准的都放这儿，不自己发明规则归类）
| # | 条目 | 我看到的 | 为什么拿不准 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mathematics 的 4 个 "Research groups"（Analysis and Probability 等） | 页面 H1 写 "Research groups"，但自称 "research theme"，其中 Analysis and Probability 25 名 permanent staff | 名叫 group、规模像 theme；25 人 > 一个导师能带 |
| 2 | Physics ICMCS 7 个 research theme（Astrobiology / Soft Matter / Quantum Ordering …） | 每个 theme 有方向文字与成员，无单一 lead | theme vs 组；本波未收 |
| 3 | Engineering ~35 个 research theme（Communications / Power Systems / Fluid Mechanics …） | 每个 theme 有方向文字与多名 staff，无单一 lead | 同上；只收其下具名 activity 组 |
| 4 | Vet School / Roslin 的 20 个 Division | 是「系下一级」的科层单位（Division of Bacteriology / Virology …），有方向、有人，但不是某导师的组 | 本次按「具名研究单元」收；若按严格 PI 组应降级 |
| 5 | Pathology 8 个亚专科（Breast / Lung / Neuropathology …） | 有方向文字，页面上无具名负责人、无成员名单 | 临床亚专科 vs 导师组 |
| 6 | ECA 目录里的 30 条中，CoSTAR、BRAD – Bridging Responsible AI Divides、Medellín Urban Innovation、Creative Informatics、RAFT、SEXES、Parity in Practice 等 |
挂在 "Groups and clusters" 目录下，但部分是项目/平台（CoSTAR 是全国实验室，BRAID 是项目） | 目录自己叫 group，页面证据偏向 project |
| 7 | HCA "Intellectual History Research Group" / "Irish History Research Group" | 是同一 research-groups 页下的分节（无独立 URL） | 组 vs 页内分节；本次按组收（同一 URL 5 条） |
| 8 | LLC 的 "Cultural Encounters/Dialogues"（research strand）、"Ethical Pressures on Thinking"、"Poetics Research Group" | 目录列了，但无独立页 | strand/组 的边界 |
| 9 | Business School 的 12 个 "Lab"（D3 Lab、DAIT Lab、GST Lab …） | 有独立站、有方向、有负责人自述 | Lab 是否等于「导师带的组」（多数是，但部分像跨系平台） |
| 10 | Biomedical Sciences 的 "Patrick Wild Centre"、"Simons Initiative for the Developing Brain"、"UK DRI Edinburgh" | 有独立页与方向 | 中心/计划粒度 |
| 11 | 学院级 26 个 Research Centres（ECCI、EPCC、CSTR、SCADR、Fire Safety、SMC …） | 有独立页、有方向、有负责人 | 不属于单一 School，粒度多为大一级；本波单列不混入 24 系计数 |
| 12 | IGC 的 3 个 Collaborations and Networks（One Health Genomics / Edinburgh Neuroscience / MRC National Mouse Genetics Network） | 有独立页 | 网络 vs 组 |
5-3 未验清单（显式列出，不静默跳过）
- Chemistry 的 PI 组（预计 30–40 个）：院系层无枚举入口，
/research/research-groups是空目录。未验。 - CVS 的 49 PI / INCR 的 1,200+ staff：只有 theme 聚合与 PI A–Z 索引，未逐条取 H1。未验。
- Discovery Brain Sciences 的组：只有 5 个 theme 页，无下钻。未验。
- Biology 8 个组无独立站点（Chebib group、Davies lab、Froy Group、Interthal Group、Latombe group、Rodrigo Albors、Savill Group、Spence Group）：学校目录里有名字与 PI，但表格无链接；本波以目录页 URL 入库并标记。未验独立页。
- 抓取失败但已定位的个人/组站（HTTP 0/403/404/500/503）：
www.icms.org.uk(503)、specknet.org(403)、netsys.inf.ed.ac.uk(0)、wiki.inf.ed.ac.uk/CSTR/Listen(0)、wiki.inf.ed.ac.uk/CSTR/Speak(0)、www.bucklab.org(500)、www.crm.ed.ac.uk/research/group/rna-function-germ-and-stem-cell-biology(500)、www.filmandarts-network.hss.ed.ac.uk(500)、llc.ed.ac.uk/dashkova(500)、www.wcb.ed.ac.uk(0)、lukemcnally.wordpress.com(URL 拼写hhttps://，源目录笔误)。这些条目的名称/方向取自院系目录，页面未取到。 ipsar.business-school.ed.ac.uk已跳转到 Archived microsites 页（站已归档）；Business School 目录仍挂着，本波保留并标记。- 前一轮报告里写"取不到"的
www.irr.ed.ac.uk、www.lel.ed.ac.uk/cle/、www.alzscotdrc.ed.ac.uk：本波改用regenerative-medicine.ed.ac.uk/reproductive-health.ed.ac.uk/ppls.ed.ac.uk/.../centres（浏览器）/alzscotdrc主域后已取到。 education-sport.ed.ac.uk各 Institute 页（IECS/IETL/ILE/ISPEHS）：是学院内部组织结构页，其 research 组已在/research/centres-groups-networks统一枚举；未重复逐条。- ego-browser 提示更新 0.5.1.11 → 0.5.1.12，未执行
ego-browser upgrade（需人工批准）。
5-4 名称来源说明（字段 1 的口径）
643 条里：H1 = 436、<title> 回退 = 159、院系目录官方组名 = 48。
48 条用目录名的原因：Biology 组表是 JS 表格（组名在表格单元格、无 H1）、部分外部站（wixsite/weebly/google sites）无 H1、LLC 的 4 条无独立页。JSON 里每条都带 _name_source，可复核。
6. 一句话结论
爱丁堡最终组数 643（24 个官方 School 下 617 + 学院级中心 26），组/系 ≈25.7；完备性已从"22 组"补齐到院系自述 PI 名录级别，剩余缺口只有三处且都写明了卡点——Chemistry 的 PI 组无枚举入口、CVS/INCR 只给 theme 与 PI 索引、Discovery Brain Sciences 只有 theme。