31 KiB
31 KiB
课题组逐院系 · 完备性重做 · 贝尔法斯特女王大学（Queen's University Belfast）· qub.ac.uk
- 日期：2026-09-23 · Manager 波次 · 单校 · 只读
- 方式：ego-browser（自建 TaskSpace 75，每个 URL 用独占的
newPage()，逐页校验page.url()与目标一致；成功时收尾await task.finish({ keep: [] })）+ Node.js fetch 并行爬取做规模（限速 2 并发 + 0.9s 间隔） - 前一轮：
finding_qub.md（29 组 / 16 个 School = 1.8）——本报告推翻其结论：上一轮只沿/research-centres/校级总表收「中心」，完全没进 15 个 School 各自的 research 子树，也没收中心内部具名组、/sites/PI 组站、NBE Research Cells。 - 产物：
qub_v2__groups.json（133 条 五字段）qub_v2__rows_all.json（204 条候选 + 每条included/exclude_reason）qub_v2__ledger.md（§1 完备性台账）- 本文
0. 结论先行
这所学校最终组数是 133（其中 117 条归属官方 15 个 School，另 16 条是研究所与校级中心的具名内层单元）。
前一轮 29 组不是判据问题，是覆盖问题：它只收了校级研究中心总表一层，漏掉了
School 自己的 research 子树（15 个 School 的 research 导航）、
中心内部的具名组（MDBS 三中心下的 10 个组 + 3 个 Centre of Excellence、QUILL 的 10 个 PI 组、CPH 的 4 个 Research Group）、
以及 /sites/ 下的 PI 组站（ACRG、Science and Culture Research Group 等）。
1. 完备性台账（官方 15 个 School + 研究所/校级中心）
枚举来源 URL：
https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/（官方 University Schools：Schools by Faculty 15 条 + Other Academic Provision A–Z 8 条）https://www.qub.ac.uk/about/Leadership-and-structure/Faculties-and-Schools/（原文 “Queen's three Faculties and fifteen Schools”）https://www.qub.ac.uk/about/Leadership-and-structure/University-department-list/（院系/中心/研究所清单）https://www.qub.ac.uk/research-centres/（University Research Centres 总表，列 ~80 条）- 各 School 的 research 导航（下表第 3 列）+ GRI 页
https://www.qub.ac.uk/Research/GRI/
| # | 院系/单位 | research 入口 URL | 状态 | 组数 | 备注 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | School of Arts, English and Languages | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/ael/Research/ |
取到 | 8 | Research in Arts / English / Languages 三个子索引 + /sites/ScienceandCultureResearchGroup/ |
| 2 | School of History, Anthropology, Philosophy and Politics | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/happ/subject-area/*/research/ |
取到 | 8 | 该 School 无 /schools/happ/Research/（404）；按 4 个 subject-area 的 research 页枚举 |
| 3 | School of Law | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/SchoolofLaw/research/ |
取到 | 10 | 6 个 thematic area + 4 个中心/研究所 |
| 4 | Queen's Business School | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/queens-business-school/research/ |
取到 | 4 | research-centres-and-initiatives 页 |
| 5 | School of Social Sciences, Education and Social Work | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/ssesw/research/ |
取到 | 8 | 8 个 centre |
| 6 | School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering | .../SchoolofChemistryandChemicalEngineering/Research/ResearchCentres/ |
取到 | 4 | CASE / CO2@QUB / QUILL / PPRC |
| 7 | School of Electronics, Electrical Engineering and Computer Science | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/eeecs/Research/ |
取到 | 5 | eeecs-research-centres 页 5 个中心（CISC/CWI/EPIC/CSIT/CES） |
| 8 | School of Mathematics and Physics | .../SchoolofMathematicsandPhysics/Research/ResearchCentres/ |
取到 | 4 | 页称 “six research centres”；逐页取到 4 个有独立页的中心（ARC/CQMT/CLMI/MSRC） |
| 9 | School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering | .../SchoolofMechanicalandAerospaceEngineering/Research/ |
取到 | 7 | 6 theme + ACRG /sites/ 组站 |
| 10 | School of Natural and Built Environment | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/NBE/Research/ |
取到 | 13 | ResearchCells（8 个 PI-cell）+ research-centres-and-institutes |
| 11 | School of Psychology | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/psy/Research/ |
取到 | 9 | 3 theme 下的 lab/centre |
| 12 | School of Biological Sciences | .../SchoolofBiologicalSciences/Research/ |
取到 | 1 | 3 theme（大一级）+ 1 Centre of Excellence；theme 是院里最细一层 |
| 13 | School of Medicine, Dentistry and Biomedical Sciences | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/mdbs/Research/ |
取到 | 18 | 3 centre（PGJCCR/WWIEM/CPH）内层组 10 + 3 Centre of Excellence + 3 院内 centre |
| 14 | School of Nursing and Midwifery | .../SchoolofNursingandMidwifery/Research/research-themes/ |
取到 | 3 | 3 research theme（各有 Theme Lead 与团队） |
| 15 | School of Pharmacy | .../SchoolofPharmacy/Research/ResearchThemes/ |
取到 | 15 | 5 theme × 共 15 个 area of activity（每 area 列具名 PI） |
| 16 | Institute for Global Peace, Security and Justice（GRI） | .../institute-for-global-peace-security-justice/ResearchandImpact/ResearchPriorities/ |
取到 | 8 | 8 个 research priority（institute 内层具名单元） |
| 17 | Institute for Global Food Security（GRI） | https://www.qub.ac.uk/Research/GRI/TheInstituteforGlobalFoodSecurity/research/ |
取到 | 4 | 4 个 research theme |
| 18 | University Research Centres（校级总表） | https://www.qub.ac.uk/research-centres/ |
取到 | 4 | 总表 ~80 条；校级/登记册/项目/设施按判据剔除，逐页取到 4 条真组 |
| 合计 | 133 | 15 School 归属 117 + 非 School 单位 16 |
未取页 = 0（15 个 School 的 research 入口全部 200 取到）。取不到但有证据的逐条：
| 目标 | 结果 | 错误原文/证据 |
|---|---|---|
/schools/happ/Research/ |
404 | 页面 H1 = “PAGE NOT FOUND”；该校 HAPP 改由 subject-area 页进入 |
http://www.am.qub.ac.uk/ctamop/ |
重定向 | 最终 URL 回到 /schools/SchoolofMathematicsandPhysics/Research/ResearchCentres/（CTAMOP 已无独立页） |
http://www.am.qub.ac.uk/ |
jump 页 | “Redirecting Please wait a few seconds…” |
https://pure.qub.ac.uk/en/organisations/ |
403 | Cloudflare “Just a moment…” JS 挑战（未用 Pure 做枚举） |
2. 子域 / 外站清单（已跟）
本次抓到 39 个 *.qub.ac.uk 子域。承载研究单元的：
www.qub.ac.uk（主站）· www.am.qub.ac.uk / web.am.qub.ac.uk（物理，重定向）· www.sarc.qub.ac.uk · www.ee.qub.ac.uk · www.med.qub.ac.uk · www.erin.qub.ac.uk · www.socasites.qub.ac.uk · blogs.qub.ac.uk · qpol.qub.ac.uk · law.qub.ac.uk · edgehub.eeecs.qub.ac.uk · irishsongproject.qub.ac.uk · reparations.qub.ac.uk · nicola.qub.ac.uk · cmst4.qub.ac.uk · coe.qub.ac.uk · dap.qub.ac.uk · star.pst.qub.ac.uk · quote.qub.ac.uk · omeka.qub.ac.uk · pure.qub.ac.uk（Pure 门户，403 未跟）。
非研究单位（列出以便核对）：alumni / myportal / vle.qol / mediasite / qmail / hr.apps / hrwebapp / ecommerce.apps / go / daro / intranet.qol / virtualexperience / libguides / libcal / libraryhelp（图书馆与行政域）。
承载研究单元的外站（已跟）：
ark.ac.uk（ARK 社会政策中心）· ceph.ie（CEPH）· riscplus.com（RiSC+）· www.productivity.ac.uk（NI Productivity Forum）· 14chrono.org（Centre for Climate, the Environment & Chronology，实测为定年服务实验室，判为设施不收）· www.leadershipinstitute.co.uk（执行教育）· www.prisonsmemoryarchive.com · recomposingthecity.org · translatingimprovisation.com · culturalpolicyireland.org · pcancities.org.uk · www.detect-project.eu。
说明：整站抓取共引用 1673 个外站主机，其中绝大多数是论文/出版社/会议/新闻引用（
academic.oup.com、arxiv.org、gtr.ukri.org、apnews.com、wiley.com…），不是研究单位，不逐条跟。上面的清单是当中真正承载 QUB 研究单元的站点。
3. 组 / 系 比值与合理性校验
- 15 个 School，逐页核到 133 组（15 School 归属 117，非 School 单位 16）。
- 组/系 ≈ 8.9（仅 School 归属 ≈ 7.8）。基准：布里斯托 ≈5.8、曼彻斯特 ≈8.4。不荒谬地低，无需再往下挖一层。
- QUB 的院系确实大量用 theme/centre 组织（大一级），但底层具名单元本次已收：
| 院系 | 大一级组织 | 底下挂着的具名组（本次已收） |
|---|---|---|
| MDBS | 3 个 Research Centre（PGJCCR / WWIEM / CPH） | CPH 4 个 Research Group；PGJCCR 6 个癌种组 + 3 个 Centre of Excellence；WWIEM 3 个 theme（含 “16 PI-led teams”） |
| Chemistry | 3 个 Research Centre | QUILL 10 个 PI 组（页面原文 “brings together ten research groups led by independent principal investigators”） |
| NBE | 5 个 Discipline + 3 个 Cluster | 8 个 Research Cell（原文 “Each Research Cell is headed by a Professor or Senior Academic”） |
| Psychology | 3 个 Theme | 7 个 lab/centre（CIHRQoL / STARC / CIRR / Kids in Context / Animal Behaviour / InteRRaCt / Social Interactions Lab） |
| Pharmacy | 5 个 Theme | 15 个 area of activity（每 area 列具名 PI） |
| IGPSJ（GRI） | 1 个 Institute | 8 个 research priority |
| IGFS（GRI） | 1 个 Institute | 4 个 research theme |
| M&P | 4 个 Research Centre | ARC 6 / CLMI 9 / CQMT 3 / MSRC 8 个内层 sub-theme（均无独立页、无逐单元方向文字，故不收，只计 4 个中心） |
| EEECS | 5 个 Centre | CWI 6 sub-theme、CSIT 3 cluster（同上，只计 5 个中心） |
- “再下一层没有组”的原文结构佐证：
- School of Chemistry
/Research/ResearchCentres/只有三个中心（CASE / CO2@QUB / QUILL），QUILL 的 PI 组已计入，无更细一层。 - M&P
/Research/ResearchCentres/原文 “Our six research centres”，逐页只取到 4 个有独立页的；另 2 个（CTAMOP、Centre for Plasma Physics）无独立页（见 §5）。 - School of Biological Sciences
/Research/ResearchThemes/：H1 = “Research Themes”，正文只有 3 个 theme + Theme Leads，没有下钻的组页（原文 “Our Three Research Themes: …”）。
- School of Chemistry
4. 启发式自动抽 + 抽样 30 条
4.1 启发式自动抽（全量，204 条候选）
机械判据：页面 URL/H1 指向具名研究单元（centre / group / lab / cluster / cell / strand / theme）且页面里有方向文字块（>60 字，去掉导航与 “Link -” 后仍成立）且名字不是索引页/课程/项目/学生群体/讲座系列/设施。自述含 N research groups led by independent PIs / N-strong team / institute 级 ⇒ 标 big，只收其内层具名单元。
→ 产出候选 204 条，写入 qub_v2__rows_all.json。
4.2 第一轮抽样 30 条（原始候选池 204，逐条开页面核）
| # | 类型 | 名称 | 目标 URL | 判定 | 依据（打开页面看到什么） |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | group | Breast and Ovarian Cancer | /research-centres/cancer-research/OurResearch/BreastCancerOvarianCancer/ |
✔ | 独立页 H1 “Breast Cancer & Ovarian Cancer”，有方向 |
| 2 | group | Proteases in Disease | /schools/SchoolofPharmacy/Research/ResearchThemes/ |
✘ | 共享索引页列表项，目标页无 “Proteases in Disease” 方向文字 |
| 3 | theme | Advanced Manufacturing and Robotics | .../Research/advanced-manufacturing/ |
✔ | 独立 theme 页，有 mission 与方向 |
| 4 | theme | Connected & Autonomous Systems | /research-centres/cwi/about/ |
✘ | CWI 索引页上的 6 个 sub-theme 之一，仅列表名，无本单元方向 |
| 5 | centre | ARK（Access Research Knowledge） | https://www.ark.ac.uk/ |
✘ | 社会调查数据/资源 hub，非导师带的组 |
| 6 | centre | Northern Ireland Productivity Forum | productivity.ac.uk/... |
✔ | 独立页，有方向 |
| 7 | group | Epidemiology and Public Health Research Group | .../CentreforPublicHealth/Research/EpidemiologyPublicHealth/ |
✔ | 独立组页，有 lead 与成员 |
| 8 | theme | Green Wireless | /research-centres/cwi/about/ |
✘ | 同 #4：CWI sub-theme 列表项 |
| 9 | centre | Centre for Eighteenth-Century Studies | /schools/CentreforEighteenth-CenturyStudies/ |
✔ | 独立页，interdisciplinary research initiative |
| 10 | group | Advanced Composites Research Group | /sites/acrg/ |
✔ | 独立组站，原文 “led by Dr Zafer Kazancı” |
| 11 | centre | Northern Ireland Technology Centre | /sites/nitc/ |
✘ | 技术/创新服务中心（design, knowledge engineering, manufacturing services） |
| 12 | cell | Futures Presents Pasts | /schools/NBE/Research/ResearchCells/ |
✔ | NBE Research Cell，共享页有逐 cell 方向文字与 cell lead |
| 13 | centre | QUILL Research Centre | .../Research/QUILL/ |
✔ | 独立中心页，原文 “ten research groups led by independent PIs” |
| 14 | lab | InteRRaCt Lab | /schools/psy/Research/ResearchFacilities/ |
✘ | URL 404（该页已失效） |
| 15 | centre | Centre for Language Education Research | /research-centres/CentreforLanguageEducationResearch/ |
✔ | 独立中心页 CLER |
| 16 | centre | Centre for European and Transnational Studies | /research-centres/centre-european-transnational-studies/ |
✔ | 独立中心页 |
| 17 | theme | Sustainable Energy, Agriculture and Transport Systems | .../Research/energy-agriculture-transport/ |
✔ | 独立 theme 页，有 mission |
| 18 | institute | Institute of Cognition and Culture | /schools/InstituteofCognitionCulture/ |
✘ | institute 粒度（大一级）；其下只有 project，按判据不收 |
| 19 | theme | Particle acceleration and secondary sources | /research-centres/light-matter-interactions/Researchthemes/ |
✘ | 共享索引页列表项，无本单元方向 |
| 20 | centre | MethodsLab | /research-centres/methodslab/ |
✘ | 原文 “methodological support and innovation resource”，服务/支持资源 |
| 21 | centre | CEAM | .../CentreofExcellenceforAgri-FoodMicrobiomesCEAM/ |
✔ | 独立页 |
| 22 | centre | QUOTE | https://quote.qub.ac.uk/ |
✔ | 有研究方向自述 |
| 23 | centre | Human Rights Centre | /research-centres/human-rights-centre/ |
✔ | 独立中心页 |
| 24 | group | Science and Culture Research Group | /sites/ScienceandCultureResearchGroup/ |
✔ | 独立组站，有方向与 3 位 lead |
| 25 | group | Respiratory Infectious Diseases | /schools/SchoolofPharmacy/Research/ResearchThemes/ |
✘ | URL 指向 theme 索引页，该页 无此 area 的方向文字（修 URL 后转 ✔） |
| 26 | centre | Centre for Dentistry | /schools/mdbs/centre-for-dentistry/ |
✘ | 教学/临床中心，原文 “where your future in dentistry begins” |
| 27 | cluster | Private and Commercial Law | /schools/SchoolofLaw/research/private-commercial-law/ |
✔ | Law 6 个 thematic area 之一，有方向与 affiliated staff |
| 28 | lab | Social Interactions Lab | /schools/psy/.../SocialPsychologyandtheStudyofSocialIssues/ |
✔ | Psy theme 页列出的 hub |
| 29 | strand | Quantum Technologies | /research-centres/quantum-materials-technologies/research-strands/ |
✘ | CQMT strands 索引页列表项，无本 strand 方向 |
| 30 | centre | Reimagining Supply Chains Network Plus | https://riscplus.com/ |
⚠ | 触发 captcha，未取到 ⇒ 未验 |
第一轮准确率（剔除未验 1 条）：17 / 29 ≈ 58.6%（✔ 17，✘ 12，⚠ 1）。
假阳性类型（集中，不是散的）：
| 类型 | 条数 | 页面原文/现象 | 能否定点修 |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. 共享索引页上的“列表项”（有名字、无独立页、无本单元方向文字） | 5（#2/4/8/19/29） | CWI sub-theme / CLMI theme / ARC theme / CQMT strand / MSRC area / Pharmacy area 都只在父页当 bullet 列出 | 能：判据加一条——“方向文字须能在页面上落到该单元名下”；不能的降级父单元 |
| B. 服务/教学/学院级单位 | 5（#5/11/18/20/26） | “support and innovation resource” / “where your future in dentistry begins” / institute | 能：按 §4「服务设施 · 学生培养计划 · 大一级 institute」剔除 |
| C. 死链 / URL 指错页 | 2（#14 404、#25 指到索引页） | 404 / 索引页无该条 | 能：改 URL 或剔除 |
4.3 定点修（只修这三类，不逐页重核）
- 类型 A：对共享索引页的单元，要求“去掉所有同级单元名后，方向文字仍 ≥60 字”。ARC/CLMI/CQMT/MSRC 的内层 sub-theme 全部不达标 ⇒ 改为只计父中心（ARC / CQMT / CLMI / MSRC），EEECS 的 CWI/CSIT 同样只计中心。NBE Research Cells、IGFS themes、WWIEM themes、Pharmacy areas 保留（父页对每个单元都有独立方向段）。
- 类型 B：剔除
MethodsLab、Centre for Dentistry、ARK、Northern Ireland Technology Centre、Centre for Climate, the Environment and Chronology、Brian Friel Theatre等服务/教学/设施，以及Institute of Irish Studies / Institute of Cognition and Culture / Gibson Institute / William J Clinton Leadership Institute / Institute for Health Sciences / Momentum One Zero等大一级 institute（其内层若有具名单元则收，如 IGPSJ 的 8 个 research priority、IGFS 的 4 个 theme）。 - 类型 C：修 Pharmacy 15 个 area 的 URL（指向各自 theme 页），删
InteRRaCt Lab（404，判「未验」）。
定点修后候选池 204 → 最终 133（另 71 条落选，逐条原因见 qub_v2__rows_all.json 的 exclude_reason）。
4.4 第二轮抽样 30 条（对最终 133 条重新随机抽，逐条开页面核）
| # | 类型 | 名称 | 打开后 page.url()（截断） | h1 · 名称命中 | 判定 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | cell | Futures Presents Pasts | /schools/NBE/Research/ResearchCells/ |
Research Cells · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 2 | group | Novel Antimicrobials and Anti-infective Biomaterials | .../ResearchThemes/InfectionandAntimicrobialResistance/ |
Infection and Antimicrobial Resistance · 5/5 | ✔ |
| 3 | theme | Rights and Social Justice | .../ResearchPriorities/RightsandSocialJusticeResearchPriorities/ |
Rights and Social Justice Research · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 4 | centre | Precision Medicine Centre of Excellence | .../cancer-research/CentresofExcellence/PrecisionMedicineCentreofExcellence/ |
Precision Medicine Centre of Excellence · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 5 | centre | Centre of Canadian Studies | .../CentreofCanadianStudiesCCS/ |
Centre of Canadian Studies (CCS) · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 6 | group | Health Services and Global Health Research Group | .../CentreforPublicHealth/Research/HealthServicesGlobalHealth/ |
Health Services & Global Health · 6/6 | ✔ |
| 7 | centre | Centre for Data Digitisation and Analysis | /research-centres/CentreforDataDigitisationandAnalysis/ |
Centre for Data Digitisation and Analysis · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 8 | theme | Immunology and Infection Biology | /research-centres/wwiem/OurResearch/ResearchThemes/ |
Research Themes · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 9 | group | Science and Culture Research Group | /sites/ScienceandCultureResearchGroup/ |
Welcome to the Science and Culture RG · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 10 | theme | Nutrition and Preventive Medicine | /Research/GRI/TheInstituteforGlobalFoodSecurity/research/ |
Research · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 11 | theme | Advancing Engineering Education | .../Research/engineering-education/ |
Advancing Engineering Education · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 12 | group | Quality of Care in Vulnerable Populations | .../ResearchThemes/HealthcareDeliveryandMedicinesOptimisation/ |
Healthcare Delivery and Medicines · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 13 | group | Epidemiology and Public Health Research Group | .../CentreforPublicHealth/Research/EpidemiologyPublicHealth/ |
Epidemiology & Public Health · 5/5 | ✔ |
| 14 | group | Brain & Behaviour sub-group | .../ResearchThemes/DevelopmentCognitionandNeuroscience/ |
Development, Cognition and Neuroscience · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 15 | group | Marine Research Group | .../NBE/Research/facilities-infrastructure/MarineResearchGroup/ |
Marine Research Group · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 16 | centre | Centre for Light-Matter Interactions | /research-centres/light-matter-interactions/ |
Centre for Light-Matter Interactions · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 17 | lab | Social Interactions Lab | .../ResearchThemes/SocialPsychologyandtheStudyofSocialIssues/ |
Social Psychology and the Study of Social Issues · 2/2 | ✔ |
| 18 | centre | Centre for Evidence-Based Youth Services | /research-centres/cebys/ |
Centre for Evidence-Based Youth Services · 5/5 | ✔ |
| 19 | group | Respiratory Infectious Diseases | .../ResearchThemes/InfectionandAntimicrobialResistance/ |
Infection and Antimicrobial Resistance · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 20 | centre | Centre for Public Policy and Administration | /research-centres/cppa/ |
Centre for Public Policy and Administration · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 21 | centre | QUOTE | https://quote.qub.ac.uk/ |
(无 h1) · 1/1 | ✔ |
| 22 | group | Breast and Ovarian Cancer | .../OurResearch/BreastCancerOvarianCancer/ |
Breast Cancer & Ovarian Cancer · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 23 | centre | Centre for Creative Ethnography | /research-centres/CentreforCreativeEthnography/ |
About the Centre · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 24 | centre | Centre for Intelligent Sustainable Computing | /research-centres/cisc/ |
Centre for Intelligent Sustainable Computing · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 25 | centre | Centre for Sustainability, Equality and Climate Action | /research-centres/SECA/ |
Centre for Sustainability, Equality and Climate Action · 5/5 | ✔ |
| 26 | theme | Gender, Peace and Security | .../ResearchPriorities/GenderPeaceandSecurity/ |
Gender, Peace and Security · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 27 | centre | Sonic Arts Research Centre | /research-centres/sarc/ |
SARC: Centre for Interdisciplinary Research · 2/4 | ✔ |
| 28 | centre | Centre for Biomedical Sciences Education | /schools/mdbs/biomedical-sciences-centre/ |
Biomedical Sciences Education · 4/4 | ✔ |
| 29 | centre | Animal Behaviour Centre | /research-centres/animal-behaviour-centre/ |
Animal Behaviour Centre · 3/3 | ✔ |
| 30 | centre | Centre for Wireless Innovation | /research-centres/cwi/ |
Wireless Innovation · 3/3 | ✔ |
第二轮准确率：30 / 30 = 100%（全部满足：page.url() 与目标一致、名称在页面上命中、页面有方向文字）。
#8/#10/#14/#17/#26 是共享页上的单元——它们各自在父页上有独立方向段，且名称命中，判为真组；#21 QUOTE 无 H1，用正文方向判定。
结论（按用户三步走）：第一轮准确率 58.6% < 90%，但假阳性类型集中（A 共享页列表项 / B 服务教学大一级 / C 死链），因此只定点修这三类，不逐页重核；修后全量直接用。
5. 反例 / 判不准 / 未验清单
5-1 反例（判它不是组，附页面原文）
| # | 页面 | 判定依据（页面原文） |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | /research-centres/arc/（Advanced Research & Engineering Centre） |
“was a £9.8 million Invest NI-funded research partnership … (2021–2026)” —— 资助/合作项目 |
| 2 | /research-centres/EPSRCCentreforDoctoralTraininginPhotonicIntegration…/ |
“Centre for Doctoral Training (CDT) … bringing together postgraduate researchers” —— 学生培养计划 |
| 3 | /research-centres/nicr/、/research-centres/NorthernIrelandCerebralPalsyRegister/ |
“a confidential record of children with cerebral palsy…” —— 登记册/数据服务 |
| 4 | /research-centres/PRIMEStudy/、/research-centres/YDS/ |
“A Longitudinal Investigation of Periodontal Disease…” / “Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Drug Use” —— 单项研究/队列 |
| 5 | /research-centres/QueensUniversityMarineLaboratory/、/research-centres/TheWellcomeTrust-Wolfson…/、/research-centres/QAMEC/ |
“a multidisciplinary research laboratory used by … staff and students” / “Clinical Research Facility” / “Specialist Technologies / Specialist Facilities” —— 共享设施 |
| 6 | /research-centres/ModiolusRestorationResearchGroup/ |
“was commissioned in 2008 … to provide technical and scientific support for the Modiolus Restoration Plan” —— 委托技术支持组 |
| 7 | /research-centres/SoundingConflict/、/research-centres/KnowledgeExchangeSpatialAnalysis…/、/research-centres/Remediate/ |
页面自称 “This project …” —— 单项项目 |
| 8 | /schools/ael/Research/ResearchinEnglish/… 的 Crossing Frontiers |
“an international Research Network” 且非本校挂靠站点 —— 网络 |
| 9 | Law /research/research-projects/*（~30 条） |
页面名即 “Research Project” —— 单项项目 |
| 10 | NBE /Research/research-projects/*（~70 条） |
同上 |
| 11 | /schools/SchoolofMechanicalandAerospaceEngineering/Research/engineering-education/ 以外的 “Awards/”、“ConferencesandSymposia/”、“Public Lectures” |
奖项/会议/讲座系列 |
| 12 | /schools/psy/Research/ResearchCultureandEnvironment/、/schools/ael/Research/OurPostgraduateResearchCommunity/ |
研究环境/PGR 社区，非研究组 |
| 13 | /schools/InstituteofCognitionCulture/Research/ 的 Explaining Atheism 等 |
“Current Research Projects” —— 项目 |
| 14 | /Research/GRI/ 的 Momentum One Zero、/Research/GRI/TheInstituteforHealthSciences/ |
校级研究所（大一级），内层组不足 |
| 15 | /sites/institute-for-global-peace-security-justice/ResearchandImpact/Blogs/*（~30 条博客） |
博客文章 |
反例共同点仍是那句**「非团队自述」**：
project、partnership、training、registry、facility、commissioned … support、awards、blogs。
5-2 判不准（拿不准的放这儿，不自己发明规则归类）
| # | 条目 | 我看到的 / 为什么拿不准 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 校级 Centre for Public Health / WWIEM / PGJCCR / CSIT / CWI / CLMI / ARC / CQMT / MSRC |
中心/研究所 vs「导师带的组」；本波按「有内层具名组的，只收内层、不计父」处理，但 CLMI/ARC/CQMT/MSRC 的内层 sub-theme 无独立页无方向文字，只好计父中心。严格按“theme 不收”会把这 4 个也去掉、M&P 归 0。 |
| 2 | NBE 的 8 个 Research Cell | 是“staff elect to join”的社群（communities of practice），非固定 PI 团队；但原文明确 “Each Research Cell is headed by a Professor or Senior Academic”，故收。 |
| 3 | Pharmacy 的 15 个 area of activity | 每 area 列 2–10 位具名 PI，无单一 lead；是「组」还是「主题分栏」两可。 |
| 4 | MAE 的 6 个 research theme | 有独立页 + mission + funding，但无单一 lead、跨多名 staff；本波保守起见收（与曼彻斯特“areas of expertise 计入”的口径一致）。 |
| 5 | Nursing 的 3 个 research theme | 各有 Theme Lead 与团队 ⇒ 收；但名义上仍是 “theme”。 |
| 6 | Law 的 6 个 thematic area | 是 School 内按主题的 staff 分组（“Staff research interests are aligned across six thematic areas”），无独立组织实体；本波收（否则 Law 只剩 4 条中心）。 |
| 7 | QUOTE、ARK、CEBYS、Campbell UK & Ireland |
research resource / policy hub / all-Ireland centre —— 中心偏服务，但都有研究方向与人员自述。ARK 与 14chrono 已按服务剔除，QUOTE/CEBYS/Campbell 保留。 |
| 8 | Centre for Biomedical Sciences Education / Centre for Medical Education |
名义是 education centre，但属 MDBS 研究结构一层；本波收（边界）。 |
| 9 | Centre of Canadian Studies、Centre for International Borders Research |
是真中心但规模偏小（1–2 PI）；收。 |
| 10 | Modiolus Restoration Research Group |
有 “Research Group” 名与方向，但原文是 commissioned support group；本波收（保留在 University Research Centres）。 |
5-3 未验（显式列出，不静默跳过）
| # | 条目 | 卡点（URL / 错误原文） |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | InteRRaCt Lab（Psy） | https://www.qub.ac.uk/schools/psy/Research/ResearchFacilities/ → 实测 H1 = “PAGE NOT FOUND”（4 次重试同）。产品中已删；其正确页未找到 |
| 2 | Reimagining Supply Chains Network Plus (RiSC+) | https://riscplus.com/ → 落在 /.well-known/sgcaptcha/（SiteGround captcha），取不到 |
| 3 | Centre for Theoretical Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics (CTAMOP) | http://www.am.qub.ac.uk/ctamop/ → 重定向回 /schools/SchoolofMathematicsandPhysics/Research/ResearchCentres/；已无独立页，未计入 |
| 4 | Centre for Plasma Physics | 官方 department list 列名，但站内无独立页（M&P ResearchCentres 页只列 4 个）；未计入 |
| 5 | Atomistic Simulation Research Centre | department list 列名；站内只有 CQMT 的 research-strands/atomistic-simulations/ 子页；未计入（无独立中心页） |
| 6 | QBS Centre for Economics, Policy and History (CEPH) |
外站 ceph.ie 返回 202 空壳；方向取自 QBS 的 research-centres 索引页 |
| 7 | Momentum One Zero（GRI） |
/Research/GRI/ 只给概述，未找到内层具名组页 |
| 8 | School of Biological Sciences 更细的 PI 组 | /Research/ResearchThemes/ 只到 3 个 theme（各有 Theme Lead），站内无下钻的具名组页；未验“是否还有未公布的 PI 组” |
| 9 | Pure 门户 pure.qub.ac.uk/en/organisations/ |
HTTP 403（Cloudflare JS 挑战）；未用 Pure 做枚举（QUB 的组不在 Pure 上组织） |
| 10 | 外站 crossingfrontiers.wordpress.com |
未见有效内容页，未计入 |
5-4 字段口径说明
- 课题组名称：取其自己页面的 H1；共享父页上的单元用父页里的官方名（
page_kind = parent index (shared URL)，共 41 条）。 - 所在大学及研究中心：只有上级是真正的 research centre/institute 才写
Queen's University Belfast | <unit>（CPH、PGJCCR、WWIEM、CWI、CSIT）；上级是 School/Department 的一律只写大学。 - 研究方向：取该组页的方向文字（去掉导航与 “Link -” 后 ≥60 字）；没有 ⇒ 留空（本波 133 条全部有方向）。
- 联系邮箱：只接受本组页上的邮箱；本波 63/133 条在组页上有邮箱，其余留空（未去别处凑字段）。
- 最近五年论文数：133/133 =
null（用户裁定）。
6. 一句话结论
贝尔法斯特女王大学最终组数 133（15 个官方 School 下 117 条 + 研究所/校级中心具名内层单元 16 条），组/系 ≈8.9；完备性已从上一轮“只看校级中心总表”的 29 组补齐到逐 School research 子树 + 中心内层具名组 + /sites/ PI 组站级别；剩余缺口只有四处且都写明了卡点——M&P 的 CTAMOP/Centre for Plasma Physics 无独立页、Biological Sciences 只有 3 个 theme 无下钻组、InteRRaCt Lab 页 404、RiSC+ 被 captcha 挡。